A recent ruling by Nyarugenge Intermediate Court ordering compensation to a child born after her mother was sexually assaulted could open the way for other children in similar circumstances to seek compensation, a legal expert has told The New Times.
Earlier this month, the court awarded damages to a 12-year-old child born after her mother was sexually assaulted, recognising the child as independently entitled to compensation for the harm resulting from the crime.
The assault occurred in July 2013, when the mother was 15. She became pregnant and gave birth the following year. The perpetrator was 24 at the time.
After hearing the case in October this year and considering evidence, including DNA test results, the court convicted the man and sentenced him to 15 years in prison. It also ordered him to pay Rwf2 million in damages to the child and Rwf5 million to her mother.
ALSO READ: Rwanda's fight against sexual harassment
The ruling is possibly the first of its kind in Rwanda. It has drawn attention to a gap in the country’s legal framework, which does not expressly provide for whether children born as a result of rape can independently claim compensation arising from the crime.
Speaking to The New Times, family law expert Marie Louise Mukashema said the decision could influence how similar cases are handled in future. However, she said its implications would become clearer after the higher court rules on appeals filed by both parties.
The New Times understands that both sides have appealed. The man is challenging his 15-year prison sentence, which he considers excessive, while the mother's legal team is seeking higher compensation.
"If the higher court upholds the child's entitlement to damages, lawyers could rely on the reasoning in the case when representing other children born under similar circumstances,” she said.
Mukashema noted that the legal team had to draw on legal arguments from other jurisdictions to support the child's claim because Rwanda's domestic laws do not clearly establish the right to compensation for children born as a result of rape.
In presenting the case, the legal team relied on decisions from other jurisdictions, including a 2016 ruling by the Delhi High Court in India and proceedings before the International Criminal Court (ICC).
ALSO READ: Why many GBV survivors suffer in silence rather than seek justice
Mukashema noted that the Rwandan case was significant because it asked the court to consider the child as a victim in her own right, rather than treating her only as a consequence of the crime committed against her mother.
Such a ruling can encourage other victims and their children to seek legal assistance and pursue claims they may not previously have considered, she pointed out, adding that victims should be made aware of both aspects of the justice process so that they do not leave court proceedings without considering their right to claim damages.
"The significance of the case will not be limited to the amount awarded by the court. Its wider value will depend on whether it helps other victims understand that they, too, may have a claim and encourages legal practitioners to pursue those claims,” she said.
Beyond the child's compensation claim, Mukashema said the case also highlighted how many sexual assault survivors do not know how to seek damages or follow the progress of their cases after reporting an offence.
"Under the existing procedure, a victim can seek damages during criminal proceedings or pursue a claim after the criminal case has concluded. But many survivors do not know that they have this option or understand the steps required to exercise it,” she said.