In what could be a first in Rwanda, Nyarugenge Intermediate Court has awarded damages to a 12-year-old child born as a result of sexual assault, recognising her as independently entitled to compensation for the harm arising from the crime committed against her mother. The assault took place in July 2013, when the woman was 15 years old. She became pregnant and gave birth the following year. The perpetrator was 24 at the time. ALSO READ: Why many GBV survivors suffer in silence rather than seek justice According to prosecutors, the case took years to reach court partly because the survivor faced several challenges, including not having a national identity card. She later obtained the document and attempted to pursue the case but was unable to proceed until recently. She successfully filed the case in May this year, relying on the fact that under Rwandan law, rape is an imprescriptible crime. This means that regardless of how much time has passed since the offence was committed, it can still be brought before a court and the perpetrator held accountable. The case has since been heard, with the court relying on several forms of evidence, including DNA tests, to establish whether the accused was the child's biological father. After the process, the court found that he was the child's biological father. It also considered the mother's birth records, testimony and other evidence before finding him guilty of defilement of a child. The judges sentenced him to 15 years in prison and ordered him to pay Rwf2 million in damages to the child and Rwf5 million to the mother. ALSO READ: Sexual abuse is never the victim’s fault The ruling could be a first in Rwanda, as it recognises the child as independently entitled to compensation for harm arising from the sexual violence committed against her mother. Experts say it could mark an important development in how courts address the consequences of sexual violence, including the harm suffered by children born as a result of such crimes. Through her lawyer, the mother had sought Rwf50 million in damages on behalf of the child. She argued that the circumstances surrounding the child's birth had deprived her of conditions necessary for proper development, including adequate parental support, material provision and emotional well-being. She also sought Rwf100 million in damages for herself, citing the physical, psychological and emotional harm she suffered as a result of the sexual abuse. To support the child's claim for compensation, the woman's lawyer referred to a 2016 decision by the Delhi High Court in India, which considered the position of a child born after the sexual assault of a minor. The court held that such a child could also be considered a victim of the offender's actions and was entitled to damages separate from those awarded to the mother. The Indian court further held that compensation for the child should include provision for maintenance and support. The mother's lawyer presented the decision to the Rwandan court as a legal precedent supporting the child's claim for damages. The lawyer also referred to decisions by the International Criminal Court (ICC) in the cases of DR Congo rebel leader Jean Bosco Ntaganda in 2021 and Ugandan rebel leader Dominic Ongwen in 2024. In the Ntaganda case, the ICC considered that children born as a result of rape or sexual slavery could also be recognised as victims if they suffered harm directly linked to those crimes. It also considered children who suffered indirectly from crimes committed against their mothers. ALSO READ: Rwanda's fight against sexual harassment In the Ongwen case, the ICC examined the physical and long-term consequences experienced by children born as a result of rape, including the difficult circumstances in which some were born and raised and the effects of inadequate access to basic needs. Although neither case resulted in compensation being awarded to the children concerned, the legal team relied on the decisions to support its arguments in the Rwandan proceedings. A possible first in Rwanda Evariste Murwanashyaka, Head of Programmes and National Children's Rights Observer at CLADHO, an umbrella organisation of human rights civil society organisations in Rwanda, described the ruling as a possible first in the country. He said the legal team had struggled to find a comparable case in which a child born following sexual violence against their mother had been awarded damages in their own right. “We had never come across a case in which a child from the second generation was awarded damages. The existing legal framework provides for compensation for the person who was directly subjected to the crime, but it does not expressly address the child born as a result of that crime,” he said. Murwanashyaka said the legal team initially faced resistance when it asked the court to award damages to the child. The court asked them to demonstrate whether similar claims had been recognised elsewhere before it could consider the request. “We searched in different jurisdictions but struggled to find a case that could support our argument. We eventually found the proceedings involving Ongwen, where the possibility of children born as a result of sexual violence suffering harm from those crimes was discussed,” he said. The New Times understands that both parties have appealed the ruling. The mother challenged the amount of damages awarded, arguing that the Rwf7 million granted to her and the child was too low compared with the Rwf150 million they had sought. Munyaneza, meanwhile, contested his 15-year prison sentence.