A new inquiry has cast troubling doubt on the United Nations’ accusations against the M23 rebel group in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, raising urgent questions about the integrity of the UN’s claims.

The allegations of a massacre of "Hutu farmers" stem from a joint report released last week by the UN Joint Human Rights Office (UNJHRO) and the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), which alleged that M23 fighters killed 319 civilians, including at least 48 women and 19 children, and injured 169 others across four villages in Rutshuru.

The only public source behind the allegations was the Collective of Victims of Rwandan Aggression (CVAR), whose leadership is made up of individuals tied to the armed Nyatura‑CMC militia and the FDLR groups already accused of grave crimes such as murder, kidnapping, torture and ethnic violence.

FDLR was founded and is composed of individuals responsible for the Genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda, and has largely operated from DR Congo for the past three decades.

That the UN relied, explicitly or implicitly, on such a source undermines the credibility of its own narrative.

If the United Nations genuinely stands for human rights and justice, it must abandon the habit of defaulting to politically motivated, unverified reports. The organisation has immense resources at its disposal—peacekeeping troops, financial backing, expertise. These must be deployed not to amplify questionable testimonies, but to conduct transparent, impartial fact-finding missions.

Only such rigorous investigations can support robust, defensible conclusions and shield the UN from charges of bias.

It is disheartening that, despite billions of dollars spent in the DR Congo, there remains little to show in terms of lasting peace or reconstruction. Communities continue to suffer under the weight of insecurity and neglect. If the United Nations intends to remain in eastern DR Congo, it owes the Congolese people far more than just rhetoric. The least it can do is empower residents in M23-controlled areas to rebuild their lives.

The international community must demand better. No actor—least of all the UN—should be allowed to lean on the whispers of biased groups while ignoring its own duty to seek and uphold truth.

Years of stalled reconstruction, persistent instability and mounting distrust only reinforce the urgent need for accountability, transparency, and a genuine commitment to peace. The UN must choose to stand for facts, not for politics, and above all, for the people of the DR Congo.