UN court chief: All right-thinking people must fight genocide deniers
Wednesday, April 07, 2021

The President of the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals, or the Mechanism, Judge Carmel Agius, on Wednesday, April 7, firmly moved against deniers of the 1994 Genocide against the Tutsi.

Genocide deniers, he noted, will stop at nothing in their attempts to erase or revise the past and, as such, all right-thinking people must counter the misguided arguments  of  the  genocide  deniers  with  equal,  if  not  greater  intensity  to  ensure  that  the  truth prevails  and  lessons  are  learned.

This was in his message as he participated in the programme in The Netherlands to commemorate the International Day of Reflection on the 1994 Genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda.

First, Judge Agius noted, it is difficult for the human brain to fathom the volume and scale of Rwanda’s loss whereby every single man, woman, and child who fell at the hands of génocidaires represented an entire world.   

"As I address you from my home in The Hague, far away from Rwanda, let me assure you that the Rwandan people are ever more present in my heart and in my mind. It is of paramount importance that we keep the spirit of Kwibuka living on in perpetuity," he said.

"While this remembrance plays an essential role in ensuring that momentum is not lost in bringing to account the remaining perpetrators of the genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda, it also aids in countering those who add insult to injury, who commit an additional heinous crime against the victims of these atrocities – those engaged in genocide denial."

Genocide denialism is not a new phenomenon, he noted.

Sadly, he said, history "has taught us that" as surely as night follows day, denialism follows the depraved act of Genocide.

Agius explained that the concept manifests itself in a number of different ways, the twisting of reality, the glorification of convicted criminals, the justification of the unjustifiable, and revisionism.

It is also not simply the denial of facts, he said, but a distortion of the truth.

In the digital society we live in, he noted, with access to countless unverifiable sources of information, the concept of "alternative facts” has become all too pervasive, and denialism thrives.

Will stop at nothing in attempts to erase past

Although the world’s interconnectivity via social media brings us closer together, it also serves as a platform to enable this despicable practice, the Judge said. He pointed out that through social media, génocidaires and their supporters have access to an unlimited audience to promote their outrageous narrative.

"They will stop at nothing in their attempts to erase or revise the past. If we are not vigilant, the tiniest of untruths that is allowed to go unchallenged will multiply and spread, and become even more difficult to rectify in the future."

"Therefore, all right-thinking people must counter the misguided arguments  of  the  genocide  deniers  with  equal,  if  not  greater  intensity  to  ensure  that  the  truth prevails  and  lessons  are  learned. Only  facts  can  fight  lies,  and  we  must  stand  united  to  ensure  that the facts are  being  heard."

Judge Agius stressed that the  inaction  of  the international  community,  but  also  of  every  individual,  when  confronted  with  such  denial  would  be tantamount  to complicity  in creating an  alternate  reality. 

It  would further  abet, he said, the  dehumanisation of the  survivors  and  strip  them  of  both  recognition  and  justice. 

"Denialism  does  not  only  inflict additional  pain  and  suffering  on  the  victims  of  the  genocide,  it  delays  reconciliation  and  is  an overall  danger to peace  and security," he  said. 

Moreover,  the Judge observed, Genocide  denial  is  a  direct  threat  to  international justice  and  the  rule  of  law. 

Translating ICTR judgements

The  now closed ICTR, he recalled, was  established  not  only  to  bring  justice  to  the  victims,  but  also  to  contribute  to  the  process  of national  reconciliation  and  to  the  restoration  and  maintenance  of  peace. 

The  ICTR closed its  doors  in  December  2015 after indicting 93  individuals  suspected  of  being  among  the  most  responsible for  the  1994  Genocide. 

The judge also noted that the  Mechanism  has  now  completed  the  Kinyarwanda  translations of  all  remaining  ICTR  trial  judgements,  and  is  in  the  process  of  making  them  accessible  so  that these  judgements will  be  available in the language  of, and for, the  Rwandan  people. 

Lies  written  in  ink, or  on  social  media, he said, will  not  erase  facts  written  in  blood.

"Indeed, the ICTR judgements are  filled with facts written in blood. I  reiterate  that  having  established  this  as  an  objective  fact,  it  is  important  to  confront  the  denialists and  call  evil  by  its  name."

"We  must  do this,  not  simply  to  set  the  record  straight  and  to  deliver  justice to  the  victims,  but  because  it  is  the  right  thing  to  do. Because  it  is  the  least  we  can  do  to  ensure  that the uncountable  souls who perished did not  die in vain. Of this there can be no denial."  

Olivier Nduhungirehe, the Rwandan envoy in the Netherlands, among others, thanked the Dutch government for taking its part in the global efforts against genocide denial.

"We believe that commemorations and public awareness campaigns are preventive measures of prime importance against this scourge. However, this is far from enough," he said.

This is why the Embassy, he said, together with IBUKA-Netherlands, is ready to work with the Dutch government and municipalities to find a place in Netherlands for a memorial of the Genocide against the Tutsi. They also want to ensure that the Genocide against the Tutsi - a major event in the history of humanity - is adequately taught in Dutch schools and other forums.

"Furthermore, as preventive measures are never enough to avoid the commission of a crime, we hope that the host government will consider adopting legislation against denial of the genocide against the Tutsi, on the model of laws already enacted in France and Belgium," Nduhungirehe said.