The postponement of the International Organisation of La Francophonie’s leadership election has raised questions about respect for its rules, with political analysts arguing that member states should have proceeded to a vote after failing to agree on a candidate.
Leaders instead extended Secretary-General Louise Mushikiwabo’s mandate by one year on Monday, November 16, at the 20th Francophonie Summit in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, following disagreements over whether to hold a vote or continue seeking consensus.
At the centre of the debate is a provision in the organisation’s election procedures that provides for a vote when consensus cannot be reached.
ALSO READ: Kagame hints at "petty disagreements” at Francophonie
The contest featured Rwanda’s Mushikiwabo, former Mauritanian minister Coumba Bâ, former Romanian prime minister Dacian Cioloș and former DR Congo minister Juliana Amato Lumumba. DR Congo had indicated its willingness to withdraw Lumumba’s candidacy in favour of a possible consensus around Cioloș.
Senator Evode Uwizeyimana, a political analyst, said the organisation’s regulations provided a clear way to resolve the deadlock.
Speaking during a talk show on Rwanda Broadcasting Agency (RBA), he cited the Règlement unique des instances de la Francophonie, adopted by the Ministerial Conference of La Francophonie at its 40th session in Paris on March 16, 2022.
Annex 1 provides for the secretary-general to be elected by consensus or, failing that, by a vote. The successful candidate must obtain a simple majority of votes cast by members present.
ALSO READ: Nduhungirehe speaks out on lessons from postponed OIF elections
Uwizeyimana argued that postponing the election rather than proceeding to a ballot was contrary to those rules. He described the one-year extension of Mushikiwabo’s mandate as an "unconventional solution”.
The OIF, in its account of the summit’s outcome, said member states had reached consensus neither on a candidate nor on holding a vote.
It said the Cambodian presidency proposed the extension as a compromise, allowing an election to take place in 2027. During that period, Mushikiwabo will continue in office with a mandate to clarify the electoral rules before leaving at its conclusion, according to the organisation.
ALSO READ: Mushikiwabo says one-year extension as OIF boss a victory for Africa
Political analyst Albert Rudatsimburwa said the handling of the election raised concerns about respect for institutional procedures and could undermine the OIF’s credibility.
He alleged that one country had sought to change the rules after concluding that its candidate was unlikely to win. He also referred to repeated threats to leave the organisation during the disagreement.
DR Congo had reportedly threatened to withdraw from the OIF if Mushikiwabo secured another term. Foreign media reports also alleged that French President Emmanuel Macron had asked President Paul Kagame to withdraw her candidacy.
ALSO READ: Nduhungirehe explains why Rwanda rejected request to withdraw Mushikiwabo’s bid
"I believe France played a harmful role in this process. Its position appeared inconsistent with the principles it usually promotes, particularly transparency in elections and respect for institutional procedures,” Rudatsimburwa said.
He also pointed to divisions among African countries, saying some had not followed the African Union Executive Council’s position in support of an African candidate.
Rwanda, he said, had maintained that the established procedures should be followed, including holding a vote once consensus proved impossible.
Another political analyst, Jean Baptiste Gasominari, viewed Rwanda’s refusal to withdraw Mushikiwabo’s candidacy as a stand on respect for the organisation’s rules.
"In my view, Rwanda won for a reason. It refused to be instructed to do something that was contrary to the rules and said: ‘We do not accept that,’” he said.
Gasominari argued that the failure to agree on a candidate should have led to a vote, rather than a postponement and an extension of the incumbent’s mandate.